| Platinum | Fat Albert's Restaurant |
| Platinum | Wing Shack West Greeley |
| Gold | Bricktop Grill |
| Gold | Roasty's Diner |
| Silver | The Country Inn |
| Bronze | Austin's American Grill |
| Bronze | The Cow |
| Top Pick | Epic Egg |
| Top Pick | Lit'l Bit Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | The Centennial Public House |