| Platinum | Crumbl Cookies - Greeley |
| Gold | Eileen's Colossal Cookies |
| Silver | Schwartz's Krautburger Kitchen |
| Bronze | Erin's Sugar Cookies & Sweets |
| Top Pick | Fat Albert's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Insomnia Cookies |
| Top Pick | LA Petite French Bakery |
| Top Pick | Rise and Pies |